October 2026
Exploring the reformulation ‘ripple effect’ Karsten Smet, CEO at ACI Group
Most healthier reformulation briefs begin with a single objective: reduce sugar by 30%, add fibre or bring saturated fat below a defined threshold. On the surface, each appears to involve changing just one ingredient, but that single adjustment can trigger a chain of changes throughout the entire product.
:quality(80))
Research from the Food and Drink Federation (FDF) and Argon & Co puts some numbers on that chain. Its September 2026 report found that some manufacturers’ most complex recipes took up to five years to perfect. Product trials and scale-up testing were the biggest direct cost, and skilled staff time the biggest indirect one. Contrary to what we might assume, it was relatively uncommon for the ingredient itself to be the expensive part.
Why one ingredient needs to do several jobs
Rising production costs mean no manufacturer wants to pay for an ingredient that isn’t pulling its weight, and the consumer-led clean label movement has pushed brands to cut the overall number of ingredients in food and drink. That means most components now do two or three jobs at once, so when one goes, you are rarely swapping like for like. A recipe works a lot like a Rubik’s Cube: turn one face to fix a problem and you can inadvertently scramble three others.
There is further complexity when the team reformulating a product isn’t the team that created it. The recipe might be fifteen years old, and the reasons behind each ingredient may have left the business with the people who originally chose them. Before anyone can change that product with confidence, they have to work out how it actually works.
Following one change through
A good way to illustrate this is with the example of taking sugar out of high-volume sponge cake manufacturing. Sweetness is the obvious loss, but sugar also provides bulk and holds water. It delays the setting of starch and egg so the cake can rise, softens bitter notes elsewhere in the recipe and keeps water activity low enough to protect shelf life.
So in addressing this, the formulator might bring in a soluble fibre to restore bulk. The fibre handles water differently, so batter viscosity changes and the depositor settings need adjusting accordingly. The batter behaves differently in the oven too, so bake time changes. Water activity rises, and mould-free shelf life can shorten, which is a hard problem to fix on a clean label product. A sweetener goes in to recover taste, bringing a possible flavour off-note with less sugar around to hide it.
Then there is food safety. Sugar and salt are two of the oldest and most time-tested preservation tools we have, and many additives that reformulations target do the same job. Change them, and a heat process validated for the old recipe may need validating again. One change has now become four or five ingredient decisions, a run of line trials and new sensory work. Each new ingredient has added more to the label that the brand was trying to shorten.
The FDF report shows how far these ripples can travel. One manufacturer reported installing a new dust-extraction system after a lower-sugar recipe caused problems on the line, while another put a single round of consumer testing at up to £120,000.
Treating the product as a system
Reformulation goes wrong when ingredients are judged one at a time and through the same lens. A replacement can look right in isolation and still leave the product short on texture, stability or taste.
A better approach is to map out what every ingredient contributes before anything changes, then plan the replacement as a combination. Sometimes two complementary ingredients will recreate what one sugar or fat did. Another good question to ask is whether the change needs to happen all at once. Smaller steps over several recipe cycles give the formulation and the shopper’s palate time to adjust.
Solving ingredient puzzles is how we spend much of our time at ACI Group. Our supplier partnerships show us how different ingredients behave across many applications, which helps us find combinations that protect the qualities customers buy the product for. The earlier we join the conversation, the more formulation problems we can spot before they become factory problems.
Reformulating is becoming a valuable commercial skill in its own right. Today’s reformulation might be driven by a nutrition target and the next by a supply shortage or regulatory change, but the ripple effect works the same way. The best reformulation is not necessarily the one with the fewest ingredients. It is the one that achieves the intended outcome while managing the technical, operational and commercial consequences of change.