Latest News

October 2026

When your ingredients disappear, how resilient is your formulation?

When an ingredient becomes difficult to source, manufacturers need to assess stock levels, delivery timelines and cost implications. If the disruption persists, the next question is whether an alternative can meet the formulation’s requirements without compromising product quality.

As formulators know all too well, it's never quite as simple as just finding a new ingredient. The major challenge is finding a workable, scalable solution that can meet potential technical or commercial challenges while still supporting the overall eating pleasure of the finished product.

The cocoa market offers a good example of how ingredient volatility can impact popular heritage brands. Poor harvests in West Africa drove cocoa prices to record highs in 2024/2025. Though prices have since fallen sharply, they remain above pre-2023 levels and supply conditions will influence the market for the foreseeable future.   

Manufacturers responded to the cocoa crisis in different ways. While some brands raised prices and adjusted pack sizes, others explored recipe changes. Swiss chocolatier Lindt & Sprüngli illustrated the limits of relying on price increases alone.

After raising prices to recover higher cocoa costs, the premium chocolate maker acknowledged in October 2026 that it had overestimated consumers’ willingness to pay, particularly in Germany. The company subsequently made targeted price adjustments and increased promotional activity as it sought to support demand. The experience underlines a commercial reality where recovering ingredient costs through pricing alone is difficult when consumers reconsider what they are willing to spend.  

For manufacturers, reformulation remains an option but should be assessed on its own merits. Cocoa contributes not only flavour, but colour, texture and viscosity. The art of reducing, or replacing, such an important ingredient rests on a technical understanding of how the change will affect the functional and organoleptic properties in the finished product.   

The same considerations apply to other ingredients facing costs and supply pressure, most notably whey protein.

European food-grade whey powders rose by more than 50% between January and mid-2026, as whey concentrate with 80% protein content reached record levels, exceeding 26,000 euros per tonne in some markets. Growing demand for protein-enriched foods, sports nutrition and products targeting healthy ageing will continue to add pressure on an already constrained supply base.  

Substitution is rarely straightforward

Replacing an ingredient in a formulation is not simply a matter of matching its nutrition specification or finding a lower-cost alternative. Ingredients with similar nutrition values can behave very differently during processing and in the finished product.   

Protein is a good example. Whey and soy proteins differ in solubility, gelation, emulsification, heat response and pH. The significance of those differences depends on the application. A protein shake needs the right dispersion and stability, while a nutrition bar may rely on protein functionality to achieve its structure, texture and moisture profile.

These factors determine whether an alternative is technically suitable and commercially viable. A lower purchase price may be attractive, but the overall assessment also needs to account for development time, processing adjustments, quality testing and sensory performance.

Finding alternatives that work

Access to a broad ingredient portfolio and the expertise to assess functional requirements can help manufacturers investigate their options.

Through our supplier partnerships, including IFF, ACI Group can help manufacturers explore alternatives suited to specific formulation needs. IFF’s SUPRO® soy protein portfolio, for example, offers options for partial or full whey replacement in suitable applications. Soy protein brings its own nutritional and functional properties, but the appropriate grade and inclusion level will depend on the product, processing conditions and desired outcome. 

GoodMills Innovation’s cereal-based ingredients offer further options in applications where properties such as water absorption, binding, texture or fibre content are important. Here, the starting point is to identify the function that needs to be retained, then assess whether an alternative ingredient or combination can deliver the required performance. 

Neither approach is a universal magic-bullet solution. Laboratory assessment and production trials remain important for establishing compatibility, determining inclusion levels and identifying any necessary adjustments to the formulation.

 At ACI Group, it is a priority for our team to work with manufacturers to connect ingredient options with application requirements and to assist technical and procurement teams in investigating potential replacements and assessing the practical implications of reformulation.

Planning for change

Resilience does not mean keeping a ready-made substitute for every raw material. It does mean identifying the ingredients most exposed to price or supply volatility, understanding their contribution to product performance, and knowing where viable alternatives might exist. 

For procurement and technical teams, that knowledge can inform supplier discussions, risk assessments and product development priorities well before a shortage affects production.

As the ingredient market remains volatile, understanding the options that are technically and commercially realistic can give manufacturers more scope to respond without rushing decisions that compromise quality, functionality, or consumer experience.

To explore options that fit your formulation and production environment, speak to an ACI Group ingredient specialist; click here.

Contact Us

Cookies

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more about cookies